If you’re looking for a treat to serve on St. Patrick’s Day, these shamrock cookies are certainly festive by paying homage to the patron saint of Ireland. While I usually bake a batch of Guinness brownies on March 17th, I thought sugar cookies would be really fun this year because my oldest loves to decorate them. (Disclaimer—I did pipe buttercream on the pictured sugar cookies myself even though if you look closely, sprinkles are covering some ugly spots… not a pro over here!)
These Vanilla Bean Shamrock Cookies Are:
Easy to make and decorate Festive for St. Patrick’s Day Soft & thick if you don’t roll the dough too thin Wonderfully buttery Flavored with real vanilla bean
And there’s something to say about these shamrock cookies even without the buttercream—they’re so buttery, remind me of shortbread, and the vanilla bean flavor really shines through! Let me share some helpful advice and step-by-step photos so you get this recipe right on the first time:
My Absolute Best Sugar Cookie Recipe
If you haven’t tried my sugar cookies yet, now is the time! I use that sugar cookie dough for nearly all of my shaped sugar cookies and you can find them all on the new Cut Out Cookies page. Loved by many, the sugar cookies are soft, thick, hold their shape in the oven, and have a flat surface ready for decorating. It’s a classic recipe that’s simple yet easily versatile, like vanilla cupcakes (another favorite!). Today’s recipe is the same as my sugar cookies recipe only you’ll add vanilla bean and we’re taking a small step away from traditional royal icing, too. For today’s shamrock cookies:
Vanilla Bean: Add the seeds scraped from 1 whole vanilla bean. If you can’t find vanilla bean in your grocery store, you can order some online. I use and love these exact vanilla beans—and they’re usually what I use for homemade vanilla extract and homemade vanilla sugar too. Optional Vanilla Sugar: Speaking of homemade vanilla sugar… have you ever used it in baking before? Today’s recipe is the perfect place for vanilla sugar because this type of sugar is best used in recipes where vanilla is the prominent flavor. Just use it as a 1:1 replacement for regular granulated sugar. It’s optional though; while I’ve made these sugar cookies with vanilla sugar before, I didn’t use it in today’s pictured cookies. Cookie Cutter: You can use today’s vanilla bean sugar cookie dough with any cookie cutter. For the shamrocks, I used the medium and small cookie cutters from this exact shamrock cookie cutter set. I know the store Michaels carries shamrock cookie cutters and if you want to purchase a single shamrock cookie cutter, this 3-inch size is a great option.
The Trick is the Order of Steps
After the cookie dough comes together, roll the dough out and chill the rolled out sections of dough. Cut the chilled dough into shamrocks or other shapes and then bake. Notice how I roll out the dough BEFORE chilling it in the refrigerator? That’s the trick and let me explain why it works. To prevent the cookies from over-spreading, the cookie dough must be refrigerated first. Roll the dough out right after you prepare it and then chill it. (At this point the dough is too soft to cut into shapes.) Don’t chill the cookie dough and then try to roll it out because it will be too cold and stiff to roll. I divide the dough in half before rolling it out and highly recommend you do the same because smaller sections of dough are a lot easier to handle. I do this any time I make sugar cookies, for any occasion like these Valentine’s Day cookies, Easter cookies, fireworks cookies, and Christmas sugar cookies. (Same dough recipe.) Another trick! Roll out the cookie dough directly on a silicone baking mat or parchment paper so you can easily transfer it to the refrigerator. Pick it up, put it on a baking sheet, and place it in the refrigerator. If you don’t have enough room for two baking sheets in your refrigerator, stack the pieces of rolled out dough on top of each other. (That’s what I do.) After chilling the rolled out dough, it’s ready to shape and bake: If you want to bust out your cookie decorating supplies for these vanilla bean shamrock cookies, you can use royal icing or easier cookie icing. I have a helpful video tutorial for how to decorate sugar cookies, too. Or, use vanilla bean buttercream like the pictured cookies. The vanilla bean buttercream recipe below is similar to regular vanilla buttercream, but makes just enough to frost the batch of cookies whether you use a piping tip, knife, or icing spatula to decorate. And like the sugar cookies, the frosting includes vanilla bean. We also love these with salted caramel frosting spread on top.
Decorating St. Patrick’s Day Cookies with Buttercream
This frosting doesn’t really crust: Though the frosting somewhat sets, it doesn’t fully crust. If you prefer a crusting buttercream, you can replace half of the butter with shortening. You can tint this frosting: Feel free to tint the vanilla bean buttercream. So the buttercream maintains its consistency, I recommend gel food coloring. I used Americolor leaf green. Though I will say that I loved how the cookies with uncolored buttercream looked because you can really see the vanilla bean specks! Make it two-toned: Do you remember when I showed you how to make two-toned frosting roses? Some of the pictured shamrock cookies have two-toned green buttercream. To do that, spoon 2 or more colors of buttercream into your piping bag. I used uncolored buttercream (white-ish) and green. When you pipe, the colors will swirl together and each frosted cookie will look different. Very pretty!
To easily fill a piping bag with frosting, fit the piping bag into a tall cup first. The cup holds the piping bag open and upright which makes it really easy to fill. And don’t worry, if you totally mess up when decorating cookies with buttercream, sprinkles can hide your mistake. Let me know if you try these vanilla bean cookies—shamrock shaped, decorated, plain, however!
More St. Patrick’s Day Desserts
Guinness Brownies Pistachio Cake Baileys & Coffee Cupcakes Mint Chocolate Checkerboard Cookies Guinness Cupcakes Guinness Chocolate Cake Lucky Charms Treats
